Host phenotype classification from human microbiome data is mainly driven by the presence of microbial taxa.

Machine learning-based classification approaches are widely used to predict host phenotypes from microbiome data. Classifiers are typically employed by considering operational taxonomic units or relative abundance profiles as input features. Such types of data are intrinsically sparse, which opens the opportunity to make predictions from the presence/absence rather than the relative abundance of microbial taxa. This also poses the question whether it is the presence rather than the abundance of particular taxa to be relevant for discrimination purposes, an aspect that has been so far overlooked in the literature. In this paper, we aim at filling this gap by performing a meta-analysis on 4,128 publicly available metagenomes associated with multiple case-control studies. At species-level taxonomic resolution, we show that it is the presence rather than the relative abundance of specific microbial taxa to be important when building classification models. Such findings are robust to the choice of the classifier and confirmed by statistical tests applied to identifying differentially abundant/present taxa. Results are further confirmed at coarser taxonomic resolutions and validated on 4,026 additional 16S rRNA samples coming from 30 public case-control studies. Author summary: The composition of the human microbiome has been linked to a large number of different diseases. In this context, classification methodologies based on machine learning approaches have represented a promising tool for diagnostic purposes from metagenomics data. The link between microbial population composition and host phenotypes has been usually performed by considering taxonomic profiles represented by relative abundances of microbial species. In this study, we show that it is more the presence rather than the relative abundance of microbial taxa to be relevant to maximize classification accuracy. This is accomplished by conducting a meta-analysis on more than 4,000 shotgun metagenomes coming from 25 case-control studies and in which original relative abundance data are degraded to presence/absence profiles. Findings are also extended to 16S rRNA data and advance the research field in building prediction models directly from human microbiome data. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]