Back to Search Start Over

Playing God: Symbolic Arguments Against Technology.

Authors :
Simons, Massimiliano
Source :
NanoEthics. Aug2022, Vol. 16 Issue 2, p151-165. 15p.
Publication Year :
2022

Abstract

In ethical reflections on new technologies, a specific type of argument often pops up, which criticizes scientists for "playing God" with these new technological possibilities. The first part of this article is an examination of how these arguments have been interpreted in the literature. Subsequently, this article aims to reinterpret these arguments as symbolic arguments: they are grounded not so much in a set of ontological or empirical claims, but concern symbolic classificatory schemes that ground our value judgments in the first place. Invoking symbolic arguments thus refers to how certain new technologies risk undermining our fundamental symbolic distinctions by which we organize and evaluate our interactions with the world and in society. Such symbolic distinctions, moreover, tend to be resilient against logical argumentation, mainly because they themselves form the basis on which we argue in the cultural and ethical sphere in the first place. Therefore, effective strategies to evaluate and counter these arguments require another approach, showing that these technologies either do not challenge these classifications or, if they do, how they can be accompanied by the proper actions to integrate these technologies into our society. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Details

Language :
English
ISSN :
18714757
Volume :
16
Issue :
2
Database :
Academic Search Index
Journal :
NanoEthics
Publication Type :
Academic Journal
Accession number :
159054240
Full Text :
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11569-022-00422-1