Sources of Productivity Increases in the U.S. Passenger Airline Industry: The Author's Reply.

In the paper "Sources of Productivity Increases in the U.S. Passenger Airline Industry," a log-linear cross-section function was estimated with several independent variables of the "dummy" or "shift" form. In this type of estimating procedure, the dummy variable is interpreted as a shift in the intercept due to some discrete event that is thought to influence the dependent variable. However, the intercept of the estimated linear transformed equation is a multiplicative factor in the equation before transformation. The nontransformed equation, of course, has no intercept. For this reason, the impact of technical change on cost cannot be determined from the equation directly. Using some values for each of the continuous independent variables, use the equation to calculate cost. In this case the mean values of the logarithm were used. If the value of each of the dummy variables is zero, then this calculated cost is interpreted as the expected annual cost of running a propeller driven plane for the sample geometric seat miles, fuel-cost, etc. Replicate this procedure with the addition of a value of unity for the first dummy variable. This is interpreted as the expected annual cost of running a turboprop plane for the sample geometric mean values of the continuous independent variables.