Preferential ligand binding to multi-state acceptor systems: comparisons of the calcium-binding and dimerization characteristics of prothrombin and fragment 1.

Consideration is given to the interactions of a ligand with self-associating acceptor systems for which preferential binding is an ambiguous term in that ligand-mediated self-association does not necessarily imply a greater binding constant for polymeric acceptor--even in instances where binding sites are preserved in the self-association process. This dilemma is shown to arise in situations involving the binding of ligand to monomeric and polymeric forms of an acceptor that also coexist in equilibrium with inactive isomeric states. For example, the ten-fold increase in the measured dimerization constant for prothrombin Fragment 1 in the presence of a saturating concentration of Ca2+ ion may well reflect the existence of a 12% greater binding constant for the interaction of metal ion with dimeric acceptor. However, that result, as well as the detailed form of the sigmoidal binding curve, are also reasonably described by another extreme model in which the monomeric and dimeric forms of the acceptor possess equal affinities for Ca2+ ion. Likewise, the fact that the same experimental dimerization constant applies to prothrombin and its Ca(2+)-saturated complex does not preclude the possibility that the active form of dimeric zymogen exhibits a 12% greater affinity for metal ion. Numerical simulations have established that characterization of the dimerization behaviour as a function of free ligand concentration should allow greater discrimination between such models of the interplay between calcium binding and self-association of prothrombin and Fragment 1. Finally, by illustrating the likelihood that the disparity in self-association behaviour of prothrombin and Fragment 1 merely reflects minor differences in the relative magnitudes of isomerization constants and/or binding constants for monomeric and dimeric states of the two acceptors, the present investigation serves to allay concern about the validity of employing the proteolytic fragment as a model of the intact zymogen.