Back to Search Start Over

Abstract 139: Understanding Why Differences in the Provision of Bystander Cpr Exist for Women Versus Men: Does the Sex of the Rescuer Matter?

Authors :
Kathryn Rappaport
Stacie L. Daugherty
Shelby K. Shelton
John D. Rice
Kathleen Adelgais
Edward P. Havranek
Daniel D. Matlock
Sarah M. Perman
Christopher E. Knoepke
Source :
Circulation. 142
Publication Year :
2020
Publisher :
Ovid Technologies (Wolters Kluwer Health), 2020.

Abstract

Introduction: Women who suffer an out of hospital cardiac arrest receive bystander cardiopulmonary resuscitation (bCPR) less often than men. We sought to determine if there were differences in potential deterrents to providing CPR if the rescuer was a man or a woman. Methods: We surveyed participants via Amazon’s Mechanical Turk, a national crowdsourcing platform, to query why women receive less bCPR than men based on the sex of the rescuer. We asked participants to rank five themes previously identified. Eligible participants were ≥18 years, US residents, and correctly defined CPR. Participants were asked to rank the 5 following themes if the sex of the rescuer was unidentified sex, male, and female: 1) Rescuers are afraid to injure or hurt women; 2) Rescuers might have a misconception that women don’t suffer cardiac arrest; 3) Rescuers are afraid to be accused of sexual assault or sexual harassment; 4) Rescuers have a fear of touching women or that the touch might be inappropriate; 5) Rescuers think that women are “faking it” or being “overdramatic.” Results: In total, 576 participants were surveyed, and 520 responses were formally analyzed. The respondents were 42.3% female, 74.2% Caucasian, 10.4% African American, and 6.7% Hispanic. To determine a “consensus” ranking, a statistical model that finds the mode of the rankings was used, generating separate results for each of the categories of rescuer. This method determined that the modal ranking for respondents asked about a female rescuer was Hurt/Injure, Touch, Overdramatic, Misconception, Sexual Assault/Harassment. By contrast, when respondents were asked about a male rescuer, the modal ranking was found to be Touch, Sexual Assault/Harassment, Hurt/Injure, Misconception, Overdramatic. When the sex of the rescuer was not identified, the modal ranking was identical to that for the male rescuer question. Conclusion: When querying the public as to why women receive less-bystander CPR than men, there were differences in response based on the sex of the rescuer. Participants reported that a male rescuer would potentially be hindered by fears of accusation of sexual assault/harassment or inappropriate touch, while female rescuers would be more deterred due to fears of causing physical injury or harm.

Details

ISSN :
15244539 and 00097322
Volume :
142
Database :
OpenAIRE
Journal :
Circulation
Accession number :
edsair.doi...........2571a045f2630728aee052336d08b5f1
Full Text :
https://doi.org/10.1161/circ.142.suppl_4.139