Dünya Sağlık Örgütü Uluslararası Sitomegalovirüs (CMV) Standardı ile Kalibre Edilmiş İki Ticari Kantitatif CMV Polimeraz Zincir Reaksiyonu Testinin Karşılaştırılması

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) viral load quantitation is important in diagnosis, follow-up, and monitoring of antiviral therapy in transplanted patients. In this study, it was aimed to compare the results of the two commercial World Health Organization (WHO) International CMV standard calibrated polymerase chain reaction tests, CMV Cobas Ampliprep/Cobas Taqman (CMV-CAP/CTM) (Roche, Germany) and Artus CMV QIASymphony-Rotorgene (CMV-QS-RGQ) (Qiagen, Germany). Both tests were performed simultaneously on 244 plasma samples. The results were measured in copies/ml and converted to IU/ml by multiplying with 0.91 for CMV-CAP/CTM and 1.64 for CMV-QS-RGQ, as specified by the manufacturers. CMV DNA was detected in 174 (71.3%) and was not detected in 52 (21.3%) of the samples and eighteen (7.4%) samples had discordant results by both of the tests. In 16 out of 18 samples with discordance, the viral load was below the dynamic measuring ranges of both tests. In one sample, CMV DNA could not be detected by CMV-CAP/CTM but detected by CMV-QS-RGQ with 497 copies/ml, and 334 copies/ml CMV DNA was detected by CMV-CAP/CTM in another sample where it could not be detected by CMV-QS-RGQ. A high degree of agreement was found between the qualitative results of the both tests (kappa= 0.80, p 0.5 log10 increased and the difference was found as statistically significant (p< 0.001). Calibrating the Roche CMV CAP/CTM and Artus CMV-QS-RGQ tests with the WHO international CMV standard did not increase comparability between quantitative results in plasma samples, on the contrary, it was found that when the results were converted to IU/ml, a measurement difference indicating biologically significant viral replication was detected between the two test results.