Systematic Comparison of Four Methods for Detection of Carbapenemase-Producing Enterobacterales Directly from Blood Cultures

Early identification of infections caused by carbapenemase-producing Enterobacterales (CPE) can help to optimize patient treatment and improve outcome. In this study, protocols for rapid detection of carbapenemase production directly from positive blood cultures were developed applying a concentration and hemolysis step before a test for carbapenemase production was performed. Four different methods (three modified colorimetric assays [β-Carba, bcCarba NP, and NeoRapid Carb] and a variation of the carbapenem inactivation method [CIM] test with blood cultures [bcCIM]) were assessed on blood cultures spiked with 185 different molecularly characterized Enterobacterales isolates. The challenge collection included 81 carbapenemase-negative isolates and 104 CPEs (OXA-48 [n = 25], NDM [n = 20], KPC [n = 18], VIM [n = 25], GIM [n = 5], OXA-48-like [n = 9], and OXA-48-like plus NDM [n = 2]). The sensitivity/specificity was 99.0%/95.1% for bcCarba NP, 99.0%/91.4% for NeoRapid Carb, 100%/95.1% for β-Carba and 100%/100% for bcCIM. Weakly hydrolyzing carbapenemases (e.g., OXA-48-like) were also well detected by the assays. The time to result was 20 to 45 min for β-Carba, 2 to 3 h for bcCarba NP, 2.5 to 2 h for NeoRapid Carb, and 18 to 24 h for bcCIM. In conclusion, all assays demonstrated good detection of CPE. The protocols can be easily implemented in any clinical microbiology laboratory and could help to optimize therapy early in bloodstream infections by CPE.