Effects of low molar concentrations of low-valence dopants on samarium oxide xerogels in the oxidative coupling of methane

The effects of low-valence dopants on the catalytic properties of samarium oxide xerogel catalysts were investigated in the oxidative coupling of methane (OCM). More specifically, very low concentrations (0.1 and 1.0 % by mol) of transition metal (Ag, Ni, and Cu) and traditional alkali metal (Li and K) dopants were investigated. At these low loadings, it was shown that transition metal dopants have potential to improve the activity and selectivity over an undoped Sm2O3 xerogel, but these dopants can only outperform alkali metal dopants under certain conditions. Even at a concentration of 0.1 mol %, the dopants significantly increased the number of basic sites compared with the pure Sm2O3 xerogel. However, no trend is evident between the number or strength of the basic sites and the activity or selectivity in the methane coupling reaction. The XRD data reveal a lattice expansion upon addition of the low valence dopants, which is consistent with substitutional doping and the formation of oxygen vacancies due to charge compensation. In most cases the majority of the dopant stayed in the lattice during reaction. The dopants were also shown to influence the Sm2O3 structure, and the dopants that were more effective in suppressing the transformation from cubic to monoclinic Sm2O3 in general resulted in the more active and selective catalysts. While the Ag- and Ni-dopants could outperform the alkali metal doped catalysts in narrow temperature ranges, the best performing catalysts were still the K-doped Sm2O3 catalysts, as the 1.0 % K catalyst exhibited the highest activity at the lowest temperature (500 °C) and the 0.1 % K-doped catalyst was the most stable during extended operation. These results indicate that transition metal dopants, at low concentrations, can positively affect the activity and selectivity of a methane coupling catalyst, such as Sm2O3, and suggests that there may be benefits to other OCM catalyst systems from traditionally non-selective dopants, as long as the concentrations are kept very low and stability issues are addressed.