Expression of BCL-2 and p53 in oncocytic (Hürthle cell) tumors of the thyroid: An immunohistochemical study

Previous studies have established that thyroid follicular neoplasms of higher malignant potential show a high p53 and low bc1-2 expression. This however has not been well studied in Oncocytic (Hurthle cell) neoplasms, the management of which remains controversial. We therefore studied the expression of p53 and bc1-2 in 18 Hurthle cell adenomas (HCA) and 8 Hurthle cell carcinomas (HCC) and compared them with their benign and malignant counterparts, respectively, including 16 follicular adenomas (FA) and 68 papillary carcinomas (PC). All 16 FA were bc1-2 positive, 4 were 2+, and 12 were 3+. On the other hand, 14/18 (78%) HCA showed bc1-2 expression, 5 were 1+, 6 were 2+, and only 3 were 3_. Similarly, HCC showed a weaker bc1-2 staining pattern compared to PC. Only 1 FA showed grade 1, p53 staining, the remaining 15 were negative, and 15/18 HCA showed p53 expression of varying grades. This difference in p53 staining was statistically significant (p=0.005). A significant p53 overexpression was also seen in HCC compared to PC (p=0.005). In conclusion, there appears to be an inverse relationship between p53 and bc1-2 expression in thyroid follicular neoplasms. A higher expression of p53 and lower levels bc1-2 in Hurthle cell neoplasms may have biological and clinical implications. This may support a more aggressive surgical treatment for HCA compared to FA.