Belief in School Meritocracy and the Legitimization of Social and Income Inequality (In press)

Educational institutions are imbued with an institutional meritocratic discourse: only merit counts for academic success. In this article, we study whether this institutional belief has an impact beyond its primary function of encouraging students to study. We propose that belief in school meritocracy has broader societal impact by legitimizing the social class hierarchy it produces and encouraging the maintenance of inequalities. The results of four studies (including one correlational study, Ntotal = 198; one experiment, Ntotal = 198 and two international data surveys; Ntotal = 88’421 in 40+ countries) indicate that belief in school meritocracy reduces the perceived unfairness of social class inequality in society, support for affirmative action policies at university and support for policies aiming at reducing income inequality. Together, these studies show that belief that schools are meritocratic carry consequences beyond the school context as it is associated with attitudes that maintain social class and economic inequality.