Small and large anemonefishes can coexist using the same patchy resources on a coral reef, before habitat destruction

Summary 1 According to meta-population models, a superior competitor and a superior disperser can coexist in a patchy environment. The two anemonefishes, a large aggressive Amphiprion clarkii Bennett and a small less-aggressive A. perideraion Bleeker, use the same host anemone Heteractis crispa Ehrenberg on a coral reef, Okinawa, Japan, where most of the hosts disappeared after the coral bleaching in 1998. Their microhabitat (host) use and coexistence, and the quality and quantity of microhabitats were investigated in 1988, 1989, 1999 and 2000 on the coral reef. Their interspecific interaction was also examined. 2 Before the habitat destruction, the two species coexisted. Although A. clarkii was behaviourally dominant over A. perideraion in a cohabiting group, A. perideraion was a superior competitor in terms of site displacement, because A. perideraion could displace a microhabitat. Adult A. clarkii emigrated from a cohabiting group probably due to the high cost of interactions with adult A. perideraion . Although it is easier to defend a small area for a larger species, sharing a host with adult A. perideraion may not pay for A. clarkii because A. clarkii needs a larger area. 3 A. clarkii was not only a superior disperser, which was able to find a vacated host, but also a pioneer species that was able to use newly settled small hosts. Larval A. clarkii settled on such a small host because they were able to move to larger hosts for future reproduction, while A. perideraion did not settle on a small host because of low mobility after settlement. Microhabitat (host) with various sizes might have promoted their coexistence. 4 After the habitat destruction, the superior competitor A. perideraion went extinct locally due probably to lack of small host utilization ability. The present study implies that the difference in body size between the two competitors plays an important role in their coexistence, because species with different body sizes can have different mobility and require different amounts of resources.