Evolving Teeth Within a Stable Masticatory Apparatus in Orkney Mice

Mice from the Orkney archipelago exhibit an important diversity regarding molar shape. While on some islands mice display a usual dental pattern, teeth from other islands display additional cusplets and unusual phenotypes that may constitute case studies for evaluating the potential functional relevance of dental changes. We developed a multifaceted approach combining 2D and 3D geometric morphometrics, dental topography, dental wear, biomechanics, estimations of masticatory muscles force, and in vivo bite force on wild-derived lab descendants exemplifying the two extreme dental morphologies. The two strains differed in the geometry of the upper and lower tooth rows, and in the topography of the upper row only. Surprisingly, the most unusual tooth morphology appeared as the least complex because tooth simplification overwhelmed the signal provided by the occurrence of additional cusplets. No difference in bite force nor muscle force was evidenced, showing that the important change in dental morphology was accommodated without major changes in the rest of the masticatory apparatus. The evolution of unusual dental phenotypes was possibly fueled by drift and inbreeding in small and isolated populations on remote islands of the archipelago. No functional counter-selection impeded this diversification, since the unusual dental phenotypes did not disrupt occlusion and mastication.