On the optimality of spatial search by continuous-time quantum walk

One of the most important algorithmic applications of quantum walks is to solve spatial search problems. A widely used quantum algorithm for this problem, introduced by Childs and Goldstone [Phys. Rev. A 70, 022314 (2004)], finds a marked node on a graph of $n$ nodes via a continuous-time quantum walk. This algorithm is said to be optimal if it can find any of the nodes in $O(\sqrt{n})$ time. However, given a graph, no general conditions for the optimality of the algorithm are known and previous works demonstrating optimal quantum search for certain graphs required an instance-specific analysis. In fact, the demonstration of necessary and sufficient conditions a graph must fulfill for quantum search to be optimal has been a long-standing open problem. In this work, we make significant progress towards solving this problem. We derive general expressions, depending on the spectral properties of the Hamiltonian driving the walk, that predict the performance of this quantum search algorithm provided certain spectral conditions are fulfilled. Our predictions are valid, for example, for (normalized) Hamiltonians whose spectral gap is considerably larger than $n^{-1/2}$. This allows us to derive necessary and sufficient conditions for optimal quantum search in this regime, as well as provide new examples of graphs where quantum search is sub-optimal. In addition, by extending this analysis, we are also able to show the optimality of quantum search for certain graphs with very small spectral gaps, such as graphs that can be efficiently partitioned into clusters. Our results imply that, to the best of our knowledge, all prior results analytically demonstrating the optimality of this algorithm for specific graphs can be recovered from our general results.
This manuscript is a significantly expanded version of the sections on the performance of the Childs and Goldstone algorithm for spatial search presented in arXiv:1807.05957v1 and arXiv:1807.05957v2, along with several additional results. Comments are welcome