Role of prostate biopsy schemes in accurate prediction of Gleason scores

Objectives To determine whether improved prostate sampling by the extended biopsy scheme also improves the accuracy of the biopsy Gleason score (bGS). Because most prostate cancer cases are now detected at an early stage with a low prostate-specific antigen level, the bGS may be the most important factor in therapeutic decision-making. Sextant biopsy schemes had poor correlation with prostatectomy Gleason scores. Extended prostate biopsies have replaced the sextant scheme because of the former’s greater cancer detection rate. Methods We identified 426 patients whose biopsy and prostatectomy specimens were reviewed at our center. To minimize the effect of stage migration, all patients before 1997 were excluded. Of the 426 included patients, 221 men had undergone sextant biopsy and 205 men extended biopsy before prostatectomy. The rate of grading concordance and the effect of different variables on the concordance rate was determined. Results The overall accuracy of the extended and sextant schemes was 68% and 48% (P