Growth hormone treatment and health-related quality of life in children and adolescents: A national, prospective, one-year controlled study

Background Health-related quality of life (HRQOL) may improve as an additional benefit of the growth hormone treatment (GHT) in children with short stature, but this effect has not been conclusively proven. Objectives To explore the direct effect of GHT on HRQOL in children starting GHT due to isolated or multiple GH deficiency (IGHD), acquired GH deficiency (AGHD) and Turner syndrome (TS), in comparison with untreated short stature controls in 18 UK centres. Methods We used recognized measures of HRQOL, the PedsQL, the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire and Youth Life Optimism Test scales to investigate the effect of GHT at 0, 6 and 12 months in children and adolescents 6-16 years with IGHD (n = 73) and AGHD (n = 45), and 22 girls with TS. 49 children with non-GHD short stature served as the controls. Results Children rated their HRQOL better than their parents. Those with IGHD and TS rated their overall HRQOL lower than the controls at baseline, psychosocial scores significantly lower in IGHD. After 12 months, the control and TS groups scored higher than UK norms. Those with AGHD had lowest HRQOL scores at all time points, due to poorer physical functioning. The controls showed the greatest improvement in the strength and difficulties scale. All measures evaluated, whether from child, parent or teacher showed an equal improvement over the year of GHT with no discernible direct treatment effect, despite reduced numbers in some patient groups. Conclusions Children with short stature resulting from GHD have lower functioning than controls but HRQOL appears to improve with GHT, most likely on account of greater attention and as a result of the retest phenomenon. We were not able to demonstrate an absolute and independent effect of GHT in itself. HRQOL should not be used as a primary measure, as in adults, to determine whether children should receive GHT.