Back to Search Start Over

Effect of radiotherapy after breast-conserving surgery on 10-year recurrence and 15-year breast cancer death: meta-analysis of individual patient data for 10,801 women in 17 randomised trials

Authors :
EARLY BREAST CANCER TRIALISTS' COLLABORATIVE GROUP (EBCTCG)
Darby, S.
Mcgale, P.
Correa, C.
Taylor, C.
Arriagada, R.
Clarke, M.
Cutter, D.
Davies, C.
Ewertz, M.
Godwin, J.
Gray, R.
Pierce, L.
Whelan, T.
Wang, Y.
Peto, R.
Albain, K
Anderson, S
Arriagada, R
Barlow, W
Bergh, J
Bliss, J
Buyse, M
Cameron, D
Carrasco, E
Clarke, M
Correa, C
Coates, A
Collins, R
Costantino, J
Cutter, D
Cuzick, J
Darby, S
Davidson, N
Davies, C
Davies, K
Delmestri, A
Di Leo, A
Dowsett, M
Elphinstone, P
Evans, V
Ewertz, M
Gelber, R
Gettins, L
Geyer, C
Goldhirsch, A
Godwin, J
Gray, R
Gregory, C
Hayes, D
Hill, C
Ingle, J
Jakesz, R
James, S
Kaufmann, M
Kerr, A
Mackinnon, E
Mcgale, P
Mchugh, T
Norton, L
Ohashi, Y
Paik, S
Pan, Hc
Perez, E
Peto, R
Piccart, M
Pierce, L
Pritchard, K
Pruneri, G
Raina, V
Ravdin, P
Robertson, J
Rutgers, E
Shao, Yf
Swain, S
Taylor, C
Valagussa, P
Viale, G
Whelan, T
Winer, E
Wang, Y
Wood, W
Abe, O
Abe, R
Enomoto, K
Kikuchi, K
Koyama, H
Masuda, H
Nomura, Y
Sakai, K
Sugimachi, K
Toi, M
Tominaga, T
Uchino, J
Yoshida, M
Haybittle, Jl
Leonard, Cf
Calais, G
Geraud, P
Collett, V
Sayer, J
Harvey, Vj
Holdaway, Im
Kay, Rg
Mason, Bh
Forbes, Jf
Wilcken, N
Bartsch, R
Dubsky, P
Fesl, C
Fohler, H
Gnant, M
Greil, R
Lang, A
Luschin-Ebengreuth, G
Marth, C
Mlineritsch, B
Samonigg, H
Singer, Cf
Steger, Gg
Stöger, H
Canney, P
Yosef, Hm
Focan, C
Peek, U
Oates, Gd
Powell, J
Durand, M
Mauriac, L
Dolci, S
Larsimont, D
Nogaret, Jm
Philippson, C
Piccart, Mj
Masood, Mb
Parker, D
Price, Jj
Lindsay, Ma
Mackey, J
Martin, M
Hupperets, Ps
Bates, T
Blamey, Rw
Chetty, U
Ellis, Io
Mallon, E
Morgan, Da
Patnick, J
Pinder, S
Olivotto, I
Ragaz, J
Berry, D
Broadwater, G
Cirrincione, C
Muss, H
Weiss, Rb
Abu-Zahra, Ht
Portnoj, Sm
Bowden, S
Brookes, C
Dunn, J
Fernando, I
Lee, M
Poole, C
Rea, D
Spooner, D
Barrett-Lee, Pj
Mansel, Re
Monypenny, Ij
Gordon, Nh
Davis, Hl
Lehingue, Y
Romestaing, P
Dubois, Jb
Delozier, T
Griffon, B
Mace Lesec'h, J
Rambert, P
Mustacchi, G
Petruzelka
Pribylova, O
Owen, Jr
Harbeck, N
Jänicke, F
Meisner, C
Schmitt, M
Thomssen, C
Meier, P
Shan, Y
Wang, X
Zhao, Db
Chen, Zm
Howell, A
Swindell, R
Burrett, Ja
Hermans, D
Hicks, C
Lay, M
Albano, J
de Oliveira CF
Gervásio, H
Gordilho, J
Johansen, H
Mouridsen, Ht
Gelman, Rs
Harris, Jr
Henderson, C
Shapiro, Cl
Christiansen, P
Ejlertsen, B
Jensen, Mb
Møller, S
Carstensen, B
Palshof, T
Trampisch, Hj
Dalesio, O
de Vries EG
Rodenhuis, S
van Tinteren, H
Comis, Rl
Davidson, Ne
Robert, N
Sledge, G
Solin, Lj
Sparano, Ja
Tormey, Dc
Dixon, Jm
Forrest, P
Jack, W
Kunkler, I
Rossbach, J
Klijn, Jg
Treurniet-Donker, Ad
van Putten WL
Rotmensz, N
Veronesi, U
Bartelink, H
Bijker, N
Bogaerts, J
Cardoso, F
Cufer, T
Julien, Jp
van de Velde CJ
Cunningham, Mp
Huovinen, R
Joensuu, H
Costa, A
Tinterri, C
Bonadonna, G
Gianni, L
Goldstein, Lj
Bonneterre, J
Fargeot, P
Fumoleau, P
Kerbrat, P
Luporsi, E
Namer, M
Eiermann, W
Hilfrich, J
Jonat, W
Kreienberg, R
Schumacher, M
Bastert, G
Rauschecker, H
Sauer, R
Sauerbrei, W
Schauer, A
Blohmer, Ju
Costa, Sd
Eidtmann, H
Gerber, G
Jackisch, C
Loibl, S
von Minckwitz, G
de Schryver, A
Vakaet, L
Belfiglio, M
Nicolucci, A
Pellegrini, F
Pirozzoli, Mc
Sacco, M
Valentini, M
Mcardle, Cs
Smith, Dc
Stallard, S
Dent, Dm
Gudgeon, Ca
Hacking, A
Murray, E
Panieri, E
Werner, Id
Segui, Ma
Galligioni, E
Lopez, M
Erazo, A
Medina, Jy
Horiguchi, J
Takei, H
Fentiman, Is
Hayward, Jl
Rubens, Rd
Skilton, D
Scheurlen, H
Sohn, Hc
Untch, M
Dafni, U
Markopoulos, C
Dafni, D
Fountzilas, G
Mavroudis, D
Klefstrom, P
Saarto, T
Gallen, M
Margreiter, R
de Lafontan, B
Mihura, J
Roché, H
Asselain, B
Salmon, Rj
Vilcoq, Jr
Bourgier, C
Koscielny, S
Laplanche, A
Lê, Mg
Spielmann, M
A'Hern, R
Ellis, P
Kilburn, L
Yarnold, Jr
Benraadt, J
Kooi, M
van de Velde AO
van Dongen JA
Vermorken, Jb
Castiglione, M
Colleoni, M
Collins, J
Forbes, J
Gelber, Rd
Lindtner, J
Price, Kn
Regan, Mm
Rudenstam, Cm
Senn, Hj
Thuerlimann, B
Bliss, Jm
Chilvers, Ce
Coombes, Rc
Hall, E
Marty, M
Possinger, K
Schmid, P
Wallwiener, D
Foster, L
George, Wd
Stewart, Hj
Stroner, P
Borovik, R
Hayat, H
Inbar, Mj
Robinson, E
Bruzzi, P
Del Mastro, L
Pronzato, P
Sertoli, Mr
Venturini, M
Camerini, T
De Palo, G
Di Mauro MG
Formelli, F
Amadori, D
Martoni, A
Pannuti, F
Camisa, R
Cocconi, G
Colozza, A
Passalacqua, R
Aogi, K
Takashima, S
Ikeda, T
Inokuchi, K
Sawa, K
Sonoo, H
Korzeniowski, S
Skolyszewski, J
Ogawa, M
Yamashita, J
Bastiaannet, E
van de Water, W
van Nes JG
Christiaens, R
Neven, P
Paridaens, R
Van den Bogaert, W
Braun, S
Janni, W
Martin, P
Romain, S
Janauer, M
Seifert, M
Sevelda, P
Zielinski, Cc
Hakes, T
Hudis, Ca
Wittes, R
Giokas, G
Kondylis, D
Lissaios, B
de la Huerta, R
Sainz, Mg
Altemus, R
Camphausen, K
Cowan, K
Danforth, D
Lichter, A
Lippman, M
O'Shaughnessy, J
Pierce, Lj
Steinberg, S
Venzon, D
Zujewski, Ja
D'Amico, C
Lioce, M
Paradiso, A
Chapman, Ja
Gelmon, K
Goss, Pe
Levine, Mn
Meyer, R
Parulekar, W
Pater, Jl
Pritchard, Ki
Shepherd, Le
Tu, D
Ohno, S
Anderson, A
Bass, G
Brown, A
Bryant, J
Dignam, J
Fisher, B
Mamounas, Ep
Redmond, C
Wickerham, L
Wolmark, N
Baum, M
Jackson, Im
Palmer, Mk
Ingle, Jn
Suman, Vj
Bengtsson, No
Emdin, S
Jonsson, H
Lythgoe, Jp
Kissin, M
Erikstein, B
Hannisdal, E
Jacobsen, Ab
Varhaug, Je
Gundersen, S
Hauer-Jensen, M
Høst, H
Nissen-Meyer, R
Mitchell, Ak
Robertson, Jf
Ueo, H
Di Palma, M
Mathé, G
Misset, Jl
Levine, M
Morimoto, K
Takatsuka, Y
Crossley, E
Harris, A
Talbot, D
Taylor, M
Martin, Al
di Blasio, B
Ivanov, V
Paltuev, R
Semiglazov, V
Brockschmidt, J
Cooper, Mr
Falkson, Ci
Ashley, S
Makris, A
Powles, Tj
Smith, Ie
Gazet, Jc
Browne, L
Graham, P
Corcoran, N
Deshpande, N
di Martino, L
Douglas, P
Lindtner, A
Notter, G
Bryant, Aj
Ewing, Gh
Firth, La
Krushen-Kosloski, Jl
Anderson, H
Killander, F
Malmström, P
Rydén, L
Arnesson, Lg
Carstensen, J
Dufmats, M
Fohlin, H
Nordenskjöld, B
Söderberg, M
Carpenter, Jt
Murray, N
Royle, Gt
Simmonds, Pd
Crowley, J
Gralow, J
Green, S
Hortobagyi, G
Livingston, R
Martino, S
Osborne, Ck
Adolfsson, J
Bondesson, T
Celebioglu, F
Dahlberg, K
Fornander, T
Fredriksson, I
Frisell, J
Göransson, E
Iiristo, M
Johansson, U
Lenner, E
Löfgren, L
Nikolaidis, P
Perbeck, L
Rotstein, S
Sandelin, K
Skoog, L
Svane, G
af Trampe, E
Wadström, C
Maibach, R
Thürlimann, B
Hakama, M
Holli, K
Isola, J
Rouhento, K
Saaristo, R
Brenner, H
Hercbergs, A
Yoshimoto, M
Paterson, Ah
Fyles, A
Meakin, Jw
Panzarella, T
Bahi, J
Reid, M
Spittle, M
Bishop, H
Bundred, Nj
Forsyth, S
Pinder, Se
Sestak, I
Deutsch, Gp
Kwong, Dl
Pai, Vr
Senanayake, F
Boccardo, F
Rubagotti, A
Hackshaw, A
Houghton, J
Ledermann, J
Monson, K
Tobias, Js
Carlomagno, C
De Laurentiis, M
De Placido, S
Williams, L
Broglio, K
Buzdar, Au
Love, Rr
Ahlgren, J
Garmo, H
Holmberg, L
Liljegren, G
Lindman, H
Wärnberg, F
Asmar, L
Jones, Se
Gluz, O
Liedtke, C
Nitz, U
Litton, A
Wallgren, A
Karlsson, P
Linderholm, Bk
Chlebowski, Rt
Caffier, H
Mcgale, P
Correa, C
Taylor, C
Arriagada, R
Clarke, M
Cutter, D
Davies, C
Ewertz, M
Godwin, J
Gray, R
Pierce, L
Whelan, T
Wang, Y
Peto, R
Early Breast Cancer Trialists' Collaborative, Group
DE LAURENTIIS, Michelino
DE PLACIDO, Sabino
Carlomagno, Chiara
Darby, S
McGale, P
Interne Geneeskunde
RS: GROW - School for Oncology and Reproduction
Other departments
CCA -Cancer Center Amsterdam
Radiotherapy
Source :
Darby, S, McGale, P, Correa, C, Taylor, T, Arriagada, R, Clarke, M, Cutter, D, Davies, C, Ewertz, M, Godwin, J, Gray, R, Pierce, L, Whelan, T, Wang, C, Peto, R & Early Breast Cancer Trialists' Collaborative Group (EBCTCG) 2011, ' Effect of radiotherapy after breast-conserving surgery on 10-year recurrence and 15-year breast cancer death: meta-analysis of individual patient data for 10,801 women in 17 randomised trials ', Lancet, vol. 378, no. 9804, pp. 1707-16 . https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(11)61629-2, Lancet, 378(9804), 1707-1716. Elsevier Science, Darby, S, McGale, P, Correa, C, Taylor, C, Arriagada, R, Clarke, M, Cutter, D, Davies, C, Ewertz, M, Godwin, J, Gray, R, Pierce, L, Whelan, T, Wang, Y, Peto, R 2011, ' Effect of radiotherapy after breast-conserving surgery on 10-year recurrence and 15-year breast cancer death : meta-analysis of individual patient data for 10,801 women in 17 randomised trials ', The Lancet, vol. 378, no. 9804, pp. 1707-16 . https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(11)61629-2, Lancet, 378(9804), 1707-1716. Elsevier Limited
Publication Year :
2011

Abstract

BACKGROUND: After breast-conserving surgery, radiotherapy reduces recurrence and breast cancer death, but it may do so more for some groups of women than for others. We describe the absolute magnitude of these reductions according to various prognostic and other patient characteristics, and relate the absolute reduction in 15-year risk of breast cancer death to the absolute reduction in 10-year recurrence risk. METHODS: We undertook a meta-analysis of individual patient data for 10,801 women in 17 randomised trials of radiotherapy versus no radiotherapy after breast-conserving surgery, 8337 of whom had pathologically confirmed node-negative (pN0) or node-positive (pN+) disease. FINDINGS: Overall, radiotherapy reduced the 10-year risk of any (ie, locoregional or distant) first recurrence from 35.0% to 19.3% (absolute reduction 15.7%, 95% CI 13.7-17.7, 2p/=20%), intermediate (10-19%), or lower (<br />link_to_OA_fulltext

Details

Language :
English
ISSN :
01406736
Database :
OpenAIRE
Journal :
Darby, S, McGale, P, Correa, C, Taylor, T, Arriagada, R, Clarke, M, Cutter, D, Davies, C, Ewertz, M, Godwin, J, Gray, R, Pierce, L, Whelan, T, Wang, C, Peto, R & Early Breast Cancer Trialists' Collaborative Group (EBCTCG) 2011, ' Effect of radiotherapy after breast-conserving surgery on 10-year recurrence and 15-year breast cancer death: meta-analysis of individual patient data for 10,801 women in 17 randomised trials ', Lancet, vol. 378, no. 9804, pp. 1707-16 . https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(11)61629-2, Lancet, 378(9804), 1707-1716. Elsevier Science, Darby, S, McGale, P, Correa, C, Taylor, C, Arriagada, R, Clarke, M, Cutter, D, Davies, C, Ewertz, M, Godwin, J, Gray, R, Pierce, L, Whelan, T, Wang, Y, Peto, R 2011, ' Effect of radiotherapy after breast-conserving surgery on 10-year recurrence and 15-year breast cancer death : meta-analysis of individual patient data for 10,801 women in 17 randomised trials ', The Lancet, vol. 378, no. 9804, pp. 1707-16 . https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(11)61629-2, Lancet, 378(9804), 1707-1716. Elsevier Limited
Accession number :
edsair.doi.dedup.....5dbe2245fa3c4425362890dc43837bec
Full Text :
https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(11)61629-2