Understanding contexts of smoking and vaping among dual users: analysis of ecological momentary assessment data

AIMS To understand dual users' cigarette and e-cigarette use patterns including the contexts in which they vape vs smoke and to understand how environmental and internal contexts and smoking patterns differ between dual users and exclusive smokers. DESIGN Longitudinal observational trial. SETTING Research center in Wisconsin, USA. PARTICIPANTS Adult dual users (n=162) and adults who exclusively smoked (n=143), with no plans to quit smoking or vaping in the next 30 days MEASUREMENTS: Participants carried smartphones for 2 weeks at baseline to record each use event for the two products and report on the context of their product use. Percent of mornings where participants vaped first vs. smoked were used to compute e-cigarette dependence. FINDINGS Hierarchical linear regression models with random slopes and intercepts examined the within- and between-subject effects of context on the likelihood of vaping (vs. smoking); significant fixed effects were tested for moderation by e-cigarette dependence. Dual users reported significantly more puffs/cigarette (mean (M)=13.1, standard deviation (SD)=10.2) than puffs/vape event (M=11.7, SD=11.5; p=0.01). E-cigarette dependence moderated the influence of social cues (t-ratio=2.4, p=0.02) and smoking restrictions (t-ratio=3.1, p=0.003) on the likelihood of vaping versus smoking (odds ratio (OR)=2.30, p=0.02). Context was more related to which product was used in those of low versus higher e-cigarette dependence. Reports of strong cravings to smoke and positive expectancies for cigarettes were associated with reduced likelihood of vaping whereas strong cravings to vape and positive vaping expectancies were related to increased likelihood of vaping. CONCLUSIONS Among dual users of cigarettes and e-cigarettes with no motivation to quit, vaping appears to be related to internal cues and more highly linked with social contexts and smoking restrictions (i.e., under stronger external stimulus control) among those with low to moderate e-cigarette dependence compared with high e-cigarette dependence. These findings illustrate the importance of contextual factors in tobacco product use amongst dual users with the influence of context being reduced at high levels of e-cigarette dependence.