Comparative studies by cell culture and in vivo implantation test on the toxicity of natural rubber latex materials

Colony assay using V79 cells, the agar diffusion assay with L929 cells, and the 7-day rabbit muscle implantation test were employed to evaluate the cytotoxicity and tissue toxicity of natural rubber latex (NRL) materials. The in vivo implantation test showed that, among 13 histological parameters, thickness of inflammatory layer was the most useful index to evaluate tissue responses quantitatively. A comparison of the in vivo and in vitro parameters revealed the following correlations between the thickness of the inflammatory layer and cytotoxicity indices: Colony assay of the extracts, IC50: r = 0.80; Agar diffusion assay, Zone index: r = 0.73; Lysis index: r = 0.61. From these results, it appears that the colony assay provides a more reliable prediction of the tissue response than the agar diffusion assay.