Using a peptide-based mass spectrometry approach to quantitate proteolysis of an intact heterogeneous procollagen substrate by BMP1 for antagonistic antibody screening

Proteases are critical proteins involved in cleaving substrates that may impact biological pathways, cellular processes, or disease progression. In the biopharmaceutical industry, modulating the levels of protease activity is an important strategy for mitigating many types of diseases. While a variety of analytical tools exist for characterizing substrate cleavages, in vitro functional screening for antibody inhibitors of protease activity using physiologically relevant intact protein substrates remains challenging. In addition, detecting such large protein substrates with high heterogeneity using high-throughput mass spectrometry screening has rarely been reported in the literature with concerns for assay robustness and sensitivity. In this study, we established a peptide-based in vitro functional screening assay for antibody inhibitors of mouse bone morphogenic protein 1 (mBMP1) metalloprotease using a heterogeneous recombinant 66-kDa mouse Procollagen I alpha 1 chain (mProcollagen) substrate. We compared several analytical tools including capillary gel electrophoresis Western blot (CE-Western blot), as well as both intact protein and peptide-based mass spectrometry (MS) to quantitate the mBMP1 proteolytic activity and its inhibition by antibodies using this heterogeneous mProcollagen substrate. We concluded that the peptide-based mass spectrometry screening assay was the most suitable approach in terms of throughput, sensitivity, and assay robustness. We then optimized our mBMP1 proteolysis reaction after characterizing the enzyme kinetics using the peptide-based MS assay. This assay resulted in Z' values ranging from 0.6 to 0.8 from the screening campaign. Among over 1200 antibodies screened, IC