Comparison of oxygen consumption calculated by Fick's principle (using a central venous catheter) and measured by indirect calorimetry

We investigated the clinical usefulness of the Fick method using central venous oxygen saturation ScvO2 and cardiac output (CO) measured by pulse dye densitometry (PDD) for monitoring oxygen consumption VO2. This prospective clinical study was performed in 28 mechanically ventilated postoperative patients after major abdominal surgery. VO2 was determined by two methods, i.e., the Fick method and indirect calorimetry. The Fick method was employed using CO measured by PDD and VO2 obtained from a central venous catheter (CVC). VO2 measured by indirect calorimetry was averaged for 15 min. Fifty-six sets of measurements were performed. VO2 values determined by the Fick method were significantly lower than those measured by indirect calorimetry (110 +/- 29 vs 148 +/- 28 ml x min(-1) x m(-2); P < 0.01). Bland and Altma analysis showed that the mean bias and precision were 33 ml x min(-1) x m(-2) and 32 ml x min(-1) x m(-2), respectively. The correlation between the two measurements of VO2 was weak (r (2) = 0.145; P = 0.0038), indicating that the Fick method using PDD and ScvO2 is not clinically acceptable for the monitoring of VO2.