Back to Search
Start Over
[External assessment of the GEMA2009 recommendations by a multidisciplinary expert panel on asthma]
- Source :
- Archivos de bronconeumologia. 46(8)
- Publication Year :
- 2010
-
Abstract
- Objectives To assess the level of agreement on the GEMA 2009 clinical recommendations by a Spanish expert panel on asthma. Materials and methods The study was divided into four stages: 1) establishment of a 9 member scientific committee (GEMA authors) for selection of GEMA recommendations to use in the survey; 2) formation of a panel of 74 professionals with expertise in this field (pulmonologists, allergists, family doctors, ear, nose and throat and paediatric specialists); 3) Delphi survey in two rounds, sent by mail, with intermediate processing of opinions and a report to the panel members; and 4) analysis and discussion of results for the Scientific Committee. Results Seventy four participants completed the two rounds of survey. During the first round, a consensus was reached in 49 out of 56 questions analysed. Following discussion by the panel, the consensus was increased to a total of 53 items in the survey. With respect to the remaining questions, Insufficient consensus was obtained on the rest of the questions, due to differing views between sub-specialists, or lack of criteria by most of the experts. Conclusions The external analysis by asthma experts from different specialities showed a high level of professional agreement with the GEMA 2009 recommendations in Spain (96.5 %). The disagreement shown in three recommendations reflect the lack of a high level evidence. These issues represent areas of interest for future research.
- Subjects :
- medicine.medical_specialty
Delphi Technique
business.industry
MEDLINE
Delphi method
General Medicine
medicine.disease
Asthma
Multidisciplinary approach
Family medicine
Practice Guidelines as Topic
medicine
Physical therapy
Family doctors
Level evidence
Humans
Allergists
business
Child
computer
Delphi
computer.programming_language
Subjects
Details
- ISSN :
- 15792129
- Volume :
- 46
- Issue :
- 8
- Database :
- OpenAIRE
- Journal :
- Archivos de bronconeumologia
- Accession number :
- edsair.doi.dedup.....efb505cb48f47cf4af9cde305ee1505b