In vitro profiling of opioid ligands using the cAMP formation inhibition assay and the β-arrestin2 recruitment assay: No two ligands have the same profile

Previously, we showed that no two of seven opioids administered by the intracerebroventricular route had the same potency rank order for evoking antinociception, constipation and respiratory depression in rats. To gain insight at the cellular level, this study was designed to systematically investigate the activity profiles of six commonly used opioid ligands using the forskolin-stimulated cAMP assay and a β-arrestin2 recruitment assay in cultured HEK-293 cells transfected with MOP(μ), DOP(δ) or KOP(κ) receptors(-r). Morphine was a potent agonist at the MOP-r in the cAMP assay whereas it was a weak agonist at the KOP-r and DOP-r. Oxycodone had moderate efficacy and low potency at the MOP-r. Buprenorphine was a potent MOP-r and DOP-r agonist; its efficacy rank order was DOP > MOP > KOP. Fentanyl was a potent agonist at the MOP-r; its efficacy rank order was MOP > DOP > KOP. For DPDPE, its agonist efficacy was confined to the DOP-r, whereas for U69593, its efficacy rank order was KOP>> MOP. For the β-arrestin2 assay, fentanyl had full efficacy at the MOP-r whereas morphine and oxycodone were weak with insignificant efficacy at DOP and KOP receptors. Buprenorphine did not recruit β-arrestin2 at all three opioid-receptors. DPDPE and U69593 had full efficacy for β-arrestin2 recruitment to the DOP-r and KOP-r respectively. Despite the low efficacy and potency of morphine, oxycodone and buprenorphine in recruiting β-arrestin2 to the MOP-r herein, these opioids all evoked respiratory depression and constipation in rats. Together, our findings discount a key role for β-arrestin2 recruitment at the MOP-r in evoking opioid-related side-effects.