Strain specificity of antimycobacterial immunity in whole blood culture after cure of tuberculosis

Bactericidal assays have facilitated development of most modern vaccines, and have been proposed as indicators of protection after vaccination against tuberculosis. We examined control of intracellular growth of Mycobacterium tuberculosis in whole blood cultures of cured TB patients and tuberculin negative healthy volunteers. Cured patients showed superior restriction of growth of the strain with which they had been infected. They similarly showed superior control of growth of a clinical strain (MP-28) that had become attenuated during passage. However, patients and healthy volunteers did not differ with regard to control of M. tuberculosis H37Ra. The ability of cured patients to control growth of the strain with which they had been infected correlated with MP-28, but not with H37Ra. These findings indicate M. tuberculosis MP-28 may be suitable to assess mycobacterial immunity as growth inhibition in whole blood culture, whereas H37Ra is not. However, additional studies will be required to confirm these observations in additional patient and microbial populations that are distinct according to geography and microbial and host genetics.