Skip to search
Skip to main content
Back to Search
Start Over
Paediatric COVID-19 mortality: a database analysis of the impact of health resource disparity
Authors :
Nick Daneman John Marshall Vinod Kumar Aasiyah Rashan Jérôme Dimet Sylvain Diamantis John F Fraser Dominique Deplanque Anne Conrad François Lellouche Heidi Gruner Detlef Kindgen-Milles Agnes Meybeck Maxime Hentzien Clotilde Allavena André Cabié Firouzé Bani-Sadr Patrick Rossignol Arjen M Dondorp Rashan Haniffa Harald Vonkeman Lionel Piroth Mathieu Blot Yaseen Arabi Marie-Pierre Debray François Angoulvant Marc Leone Maria Zambon Florentia Kaguelidou Marc Lambert Olivier Lairez Tom Solomon Carrol Gamble Laura Marsh David Richardson Christiana Kartsonaki Philippe Jouvet Asgar Rishu Eman Al Qasim Rachael Parke Srinivas Murthy Alistair Nichol Calum Semple Colin McArthur Gail Carson Jake Dunning Laura Merson Peter Horby David Maslove Nadia Malik Stephen R Knight Annelies Verbon Oana Sândulescu Patrick Archambault Paul McNally Marlene Murris Aurore Bousquet Kenneth A McLean Hugues Cordel Marc Fabre Laurence Bouillet Melissa Parker Xavier Duval Amanda Corley James Lee Kusum Menon Christian Rabaud Paul Klenerman Jean-François Timsit Jennifer Lee Nicolas Terzi Saad Nseir Gwenhaël Colin Steve Webb Kalynn Kennon Caroline Mudara Diana Hernández Yazdan Yazdanpanah Elias Iosifidis Emmanuel Roilides Yi Lin Lee Pieter Depuydt Jean-François Payen Ana Martins Samreen Ijaz Meera Chand Wei Shen Lim Bruno Levy Eric D'ortenzio Jean-Charles Preiser Pierre Delobel Claudia Figueiredo-Mello Jaques Sztajnbok Ana Freitas Ribeiro Tiphaine Goulenok Bronner P Gonçalves Arnaud Scherpereel Chloe Donohue Carlo Giaquinto Karolina Nowicka Adrien Auvet Debby Bogaert Elisabeth Botelho-Nevers Amandine Gagneux-Brunon Merce Jourdain Anne McCarthy Todd C Lee António Mesquita Sue Smith Jia Wei Jenny Lennon Antoine Khalil Nathalie Pansu Victor Fomin Audrey Barrelet Christophe Fraser Daniel Munblit Robert A Fowler William Greenhalf François-Xavier Lescure Nicolas Carlier Saye Khoo Riinu Pius Lisa Norman Louise Sigfrid Sophie Halpin Clare Jackson Antonia Ho Andrew Dagens Thomas Flament Julie Mankikian Romain Basmaci Peter Openshaw Mary Copland Brenda Reeve William Dechert Patricia Lizotte Felwa Bin Humaid Tom Fletcher Adrien Lemaignen Pierre Tattevin Christelle Delmas Hélène Espérou Claire Lévy-Marchal Olivier Picone Jeanne Sibiude Cecile Yelnik Olivia V Swann Michelle Girvan Piero L Olliaro Beatrice Alex Benjamin Bach Alexander J Mentzer Mahdad Noursadeghi Shona C Moore Massimo Palmarini Georgios Pollakis Vanessa Sancho-Shimizu Shiranee Sriskandan David Stuart Charlotte Summers Ryan S Thwaites Hayley Hardwick Wilna Oosthuyzen Fiona Griffiths Jo Dalton Egle Saviciute Stephanie Roberts Janet Harrison Marie Connor Gary Leeming Ross Hendry Victoria Shaw Jade Ghosn Lucille Blumberg Nicolas Benech James Scott-Brown Odile Launay Todd Karsies Yoan Lavie-Badie Minh Le Elise Artaud-Macari Mylène Maillet Huda Alfoudri Djura Piersma Didier Laureillard Graham S. Cooke Nicholas Sedillot Anne-Sophie Boureau Tony Trapani Laurent Abel Samuel Hinton Sally Shrapnel Heidi Dalton Guillaume Martin-Blondel Valérie Garrait Isabelle Delacroix Samantha Lissauer Malte Kohns Vasconcelos Oleksa Rewa Erlina Burhan Sara Machado Jean-Benoît Arlet Raphaël Borie Kévin Bouiller Vincent Langlois Mélanie Roriz Mical Paul Vincent Dubée Erwan L'her Michael Rose Luis Felipe Reyes Anna Beltrame Stéphanie Fry Andrew Udy Laurent Plantier Jean-Christophe Goffard Denis Malvy Nina Jamieson Irfan Khan François Dubos Jean-Sébastien Hulot Paola Rodari Paul Campbell Abigail Beane Cécile Tromeur Paul Loubet Marina Esposito-Farèse France Mentré Valérie Gaborieau Anne-Marie Guerguerian Cécile Goujard Vincent Thibault Rodrigo Díaz Patricia Gordon Sadie Kelly Bertrand Dussol Simon Forsyth Marion Schneider Nathalie Gault Marielle Buisson Yves Levy Prasan Kumar Panda Marjolein Brusse-Keizer Carine Roy Walter Picard Tom Drake Paul Tierney Olivier Sanchez Antoine Kimmoun David Thomson Nathan Peiffer-Smadja Julien Poissy Lila Bouadma Bruno Lina Maude Bouscambert Alexandre Gaymard Gilles Peytavin Jeremie Guedj Claire Andrejak Cedric Laouenan Anissa Chair Samira Laribi Marie-Capucine Tellier Sandrine Couffin-Cadiergues Soizic Le Mestre Ventzislava Petrov-Sanchez Alpha Diallo NoéMie Mercier Sarah Tubiana Marion Noret Oriane Puechal Caroline Semaille Patrick Imbert Jonathan Remppis Emmanuelle Mercier Rui Pereira Sylvie Van Der Werf Waasila Jassat Arsene Kpangon Dominique Luton Sophie Mahy Pierre-Adrien Bolze Sarah Moore Adrienne Chan Raphael Favory Daniel Mathieu Andrea Angheben Andrea Rossanese Matthew Hall Johann Auchabie Mohammed Quraishi Katharina Weil Hanna Renk Hans Martin Bosse Christophe Rapp Vincent Peigne Tae Song Dewi Guellec Mark G. Pritchard Adrian Streinu-Cercel Christl A Donnelly François Goehringer Elodie Curlier Catherine Chirouze Stéphane Jaureguiberry Ary Serpa Neto Jose Andres Calvache Laurent Bitker Hodane Yonis Neerusha Kaisbain Coline Jaud-Fischer Laurent Mandelbrot Jérémie Pasquier Juliette Patrier Gianluigi Li Bassi Sheryl Ann Abdukahil Jia Shyi Loy Filipe Cardoso Diptesh Aryal Polina Bugaeva Evert-Jan Wils Stephanie Yerkovich Julie Chas Thushan de Silva Ruth Lyons Murray Wham Sara Clohisey Seán Keating Thibault Chiarabini Agnes Sommet Hugues Aumaître Sylvie LeGac Sarah E McDonald Jeanne Truong Camille Couffignal Anne-Hélène Boivin Timo Brandenburger Diane Descamps Tala Al-Dabbous Mark Joseph Hwa Jin Cho Desy Rusmawatiningtyas Muhammad Rayhan Christel Arnold-Day Navy Lolong Ernita Akmal Menaldi Rasmin Daniel Marino Neurinda Permata Kusumastuti Stéphane Lasry Amanda Rojek Sebastien Preau Jean-Marie Turmel Nowneet Kumar Bhat Cynthia Braga Pavan Kumar Vecham Benoit Thill Karine Faure Denis Garot Grégory Corvaisier Elsa Nyamankolly Joshua Solomon Emma Clarke Patricia Fontela Eva Geraud Eva Miranda Marwali Aria Kekalih Saptadi Yuliarto Dyah Kanya Wati Ivy Cerelia Valerie Maureen Masha Jolanta Popielska Anca Streinu-Cercel Mohan Dass Pathmanathan Barbara Wanjiru Citarella Heidi Jean Dalton Nurul Najmee Abdulkadir Lara Absil Subhash Acharya Diana Adrião Younes Ait Tamlihat Kévin Alexandre Kazali Enagnon Alidjnou Nathalie Allou Rita Alves Joana Alves Cabrita Maria Amaral Nur Amira Phoebe Ampaw Séverine Ansart Sivanesen Anthonidass Carlos Alexandre Brito Ardiyan Apriyana Carolline Araujo Muhammad Ashraf Jean Baptiste Assie Amirul Asyraf Anika Atique AM Udara Attanyake Laurène Azemar Cecile Azoulay Delphine Bachelet Claudine Badr J. Kenneth Baillie Nazreen Abu Bakar Mohanaprasanth Balakrishnan Valeria Balan Renata Barbalho Wendy S. Barclay Saef Umar Barnett Marie Bartoli Joaquín Baruch Muhammad Fadhli Basri Jules Bauer Diego Fernando Rincon Alexandra Bedossa Ker Hong Bee Husna Begum Sylvie Behilill Albertus Beishuizen Marine Beluze Lionel Eric Benjiman Dehbia Benkerrou Delphine Bergeaud José Luis Sobrino Giulia Bertoli Simon Bessis Sybille Bevilcaqua Karine Bezulier Krishna Bhavsar Farah Nadiah Bidin Mohd Nazlin Kamarudin François Bissuel Jonathan Bitton Laetitia Bodenes Isabela Bolaños François Bompart Diogo Borges Olivier Bouchaud Sabelline Bouchez Dounia Bouhmani Damien Bouhour Camile Bouisse Jason Bouziotis Bianca Boxma Marielle Boyer-Besseyre Fernando Augusto Bozza Axelle Braconnier Kathy Brickell Aidan Burrell Ingrid G Bustos Denis Butnaru Eder Caceres Cyril Cadoz Rui Caetano Garcês Valentine Campana Pauline Caraux-Paz Chiara Simona Cardellino Sofia Cardoso Filipa Cardoso Thierry Carmoi Marie-Christine Carret François Martin Carrier Maire-Laure Casanova Mariana Cascão José Casimiro Nidyanara Castanheira Guylaine Castor-Alexandre François-Xavier Catherine Paolo Cattaneo Roberta Cavalin Minerva Cervantes-Gonzalez Catherine Chakveatze Christelle Chantalat Auger Jean-Marc Chapplain Anjellica Chen Matthew Pellan Cheng Antoine Cheret Julian Chica Suresh Kumar Chidambaram Leong Chin Tho Bernard Cholley Marie-Charlotte Chopin Ting Soo Chow Hiu Jian Chua Jonathan Chua Alexandra Coelho Megan Coles Pamela Combs Sabine Cornelis Alexander Daniel Cornet Arianne Joy Corpuz Emma Costigan Roxane Courtois Stéphanie Cousse Rachel Cregan Sabine Croonen Claudina Cruz Juan Luis Bermúdez Jaime Cruz Rojo Paula Custodio Ana Silva Filipe Charlene Da Silveira Juliana Damas Corinne Daniel Emmanuelle A Dankwa Jorge Dantas Etienne De Montmollin Rafael Freitas França Peter de Vries Jillian Deacon Alexa Debard Nathalie DeCastro Lauren Deconninck Romain Decours Eve Defous Eric Delaveuve Karen Delavigne Corine Delsing Elisa Demonchy Emmanuelle Denis Mathilde Desvallées Santi Dewayanti Pathik Dhanger André Dias Kévin Didier Jean-Luc Diehl Wim Dieperink Vincent Dinot Fara Diop Alphonsine Diouf Yael Dishon Félix Djossou Annemarie B. Docherty Maria Donnelly Céline Dorival James Joshua Douglas Nathalie Dournon Murray Dryden Claudio Duarte Fonseca Alexandre Ducancelle Paul Dunand Sim Choon Ean Mohammed El Sanharawi Brigitte Elharrar Philippine Eloy Isabelle Enderle Chan Chee Eng Ilka Engelmann Vincent Enouf Olivier Epaulard Martina Escher Catarina Espírito Santo João Estevão Manuel Etienne Nadia Ettalhaoui Mirjam Evers Isabelle Fabre Amna Faheem Arabella Fahy Cameron J. Fairfield Pedro Faria Ahmed Farooq Hanan Fateena Jorge Fernandes Marília Andreia Fernandes François-Xavier Ferrand Eglantine Ferrand Devouge Joana Ferrão Mário Ferraz Bernardo Ferreira Nicolas Ferriere Céline Ficko Clara Flateau Tatiana Fonseca Erwan Fourn Robert A. Fowler Marcela Vieira Freire Rostane Gaci Jean-Charles Gagnard Yasmin Gani Noelia García Barrio Esteban Garcia-Gallo Louis Gerbaud Morlaes Nuno Germano Jess Gibson Tristan Gigante Morgane Gilg Guillermo Giordano Valérie Gissot Daniel Glikman Petr Glybochko Geraldine Goco Siri Goepel Jin Yi Goh Marie Gominet Bronner P. Gonçalves Isabelle Gorenne Laure Goubert Pascal Granier Christopher A. Green Courtney Greene Segolène Greffe Albert Groenendijk Anja Grosse Lordemann Yusing Gu Martin Guego Daniela Guerreiro Romain Guery Anne Guillaumot Laurent Guilleminault Thomas Guimard Marieke Haalboom Daniel Haber Hannah Habraken Ali Hachemi Nadir Hadri Fakhir Haidri Ansley Hamer Rebecca Hamidfar Lim Yuen Han Kok Wei Hao Ewen M. Harrison Lars Heggelund Astarini Hidayah Rupert Higgins Hikombo Hitoto Yi Bin Ho Alexandre Hoctin Isabelle Hoffmann Wei Han Hoh Ikram Houas Catherine L. Hough Jimmy Ming-Yang Hsu Arfan Ikram Hajnal-Gabriela Illes Hugo Inácio Yun Sii Ing Sarah Isgett Tiago Isidoro Nadiah Ismail Margaux Isnard Danielle Jaafar Salma Jaafoura Julien Jabot Pierre Jaquet Florence Jego Anilawati Mat Jelani Ong Yiaw Joe Cédric Joseph Swosti Joshi Dafsah Juzar Ouifiya Kafif Thavamany Kaleesvran Sabina Kali Muhammad Aisar Kamaluddin Zul Amali Kamaruddin Nadiah Kamarudin Kong Yeow Kang Pratap Karpayah Anant Kataria Kevin Katz Yvelynne Kelly Younes Kerroumi Sharma Keshav Coralie Khan Quratul Ain Khan Sushil Khanal Abid Khatak Ryan Khoo Denisa Khoo Khor How Kiat Peter Kiiza Rob Klont Gry Kloumann Bekken Robin Kobbe Chamira Kodippily Vinothini Krishnan Ganesh Kumar Bharath Kumar Vijayaraghavan Demetrios Kutsogiannis Marie Lachatre Marie Lacoste Marie Lagrange Fabrice Laine Antonio Lalueza Marie Langelot-Richard Marina Lanza Delphine Lariviere Andy Law Teresa Lawrence Clément Le Bihan Cyril Le Bris Georges Le Falher Lucie Le Fevre Quentin Le Hingrat Marion Le Maréchal Gwenaël Le Moal Vincent Le Moing Hervé Le Nagard Paul Le Turnier Ema Leal Marta Leal Santos Heng Gee Lee Biing Horng Lee Laurent Lefebvre Bénédicte Lefebvre Benjamin Lefèvre Jean-Daniel Lelievre Véronique Lemee Anthony Lemeur Ha Sha Lene Quentin Lepiller Olivier Lesens Mathieu Lesouhaitier Geoffrey Liegeon Kah Chuan Lim Lim Lina Guillaume Lingas Sylvie Lion-Daolio Marine Livrozet Leong Chee Loon Diogo Lopes Anthony L. Loschner Bouchra Loufti Guillame Louis Lee Lee Low Marije Lowik Jean Christophe Lucet Carlos Lumbreras Bermejo Liem Luong Oryane Mabiala Moïse Machado Gabriel Macheda Hashmi Madiha Guillermo Maestro de la Calle Rafael Mahieu Thomas Maitre Fernando Maltez Victoria Manda Jose M. Mandei Edmund Manning Aldric Manuel Ceila Sant'Ana Malaque Samuel Markowicz Celina Turchi Martelli Martin Martinot Caroline Martins Rego Marsilla Marzukie Sabina Mason Sobia Masood Basri Mat Nor Moshe Matan Mathieu Mattei Romans Matulevics Laurence Maulin Thierry Mazzoni Cécile Mear-Passard Ogechukwu Menkiti Antoine Merckx Mayka Mergeay-Fabre Alison M. Meynert Vanina Meysonnier Amina Meziane Mehdi Mezidi Céline Michelanglei Isabelle Michelet Nor Arisah Misnan Tahira Jamal Mohamed Nik Nur Mohamed Asma Moin Agostinho Monteiro Claudia Montes Lina Morales Cely Lucia Moro Hugo Mouquet Ben Morton Clara Mouton Perrot Julien Moyet Ng Yong Muh Dzawani Muhamad Jimmy Mullaert Karl Erik Müller Himed Musaab Himasha Muvindi Gugapriyaa Muyandy Nadège Neant Nikita Nekliudov Raul Neto Anthony Nghi Duc Nguyen Nurul Amani Noordin Nurul Faten Norharizam Nurnaningsih Nurnaningsih Annmarie O'Callaghan Katie O'Hearn Agnieszka Oldakowska Piero L. Olliaro David S.Y. Ong Jee Yan Ong Saijad Orakzai Claudia Milena Orozco-Chamorro Linda O'Shea Siti Zubaidah Othman Nadia Ouamara Rachida Ouissa Eric Oziol Justine Pages Maïder Pagadoy Lai Hui Pang Aurélie Papadopoulos Bruno Pastene Christelle Paul Jorge Paulos William A. Paxton Kalaiarasu Peariasamy Miguel Pedrera Jiménez Florent Peelman Ithan D. Peltan Daniel Perez Thomas Perpoint Vincent Pestre Michele Petrovic Scott Pharand Carola Pierobon Carlos Pimentel Raquel Pinto Catarina Pires Isabelle Pironneau Hon Shen Png Ryadh Pokeerbux Maria Pokorska-Spiewak Diane Ponscarme Douwe F. Postma Diana Póvoas Gamage Dona Priyadarshani Vilmaris Quinones-Cardona Víctor Quirós González Marie Rafiq Rozanah Abd Rahman Ahmad Kashfi Rahman Giri Shan Rajahram Nagarajan Ramakrishnan José Ramalho Ahmad Afiq Ramli Blandine Rammaert Grazielle Viana Ramos Thalha Rashan Cornelius Rau Tharmini Ravi Stanislas Rebaudet Sarah Redl Attaur Rehman Martine Remy Hongru Ren Anne-Sophie Resseguier Matthieu Revest Laurent Richier Siti Nurul Ridzuan Ana L Rios Patrick Rispal Karine Risso David L. Robertson Olivier Robineau Pierre-Marie Roger Juliette Romaru Manuel Rosa-Calatrava Bénédicte Rossignol Stella Rousset Benoît Roze Clark D. Russell Musharaf Sadat Valla Sahraei Maximilien Saint-Gilles Stéphane Sallaberry Charlotte Salmon Gandonniere Hélène Salvator Zulfiqar Sandhu Pierre-François Sandrine Shirley Sarfo-Mensah Benjamine Sarton Parthena Savvidou Yen Tsen Saw Janet T. Scott Jaganathan Selvanayagam Mageswari Selvarajoo Malcolm G. Semple Rasidah Bt Senian Eric Senneville Tânia Sequeira Pablo Serrano Balazote Ellen Shadowitz Syamin Asyraf Shahidan Mohammad Shamsah Shaikh Sharjeel Catherine A. Shaw Ashraf Sheharyar Mohiuddin Shiekh Nassima Si Mohammed Ng Yong Siang Benedict Sim Heng Karisha Sivam Morgane Snacken Tze Vee Soh Rima Song Azlan Mat Soom Albert Sotto B. P Edouard Soum Sanka Sri Darshana Sarah Stabler Ymkje Stienstra Jacky Y. Suen Deepashankari Suppiah Andrey Svistunov Sarah Syahrin Shirin Tabrizi Fabio S. Taccone Lysa Tagherset Shahdattul Mawarni Taib Ewa Talarek Kim Keat Tan Yan Chyi Tan Coralie Tardivon M Azhari Taufik Richard S. Tedder Tze Yuan Tee João Teixeira Sze Kye Teoh François Téoulé Olivier Terrier Hubert Tessier-Grenier Alif Adlan Thabit Zhang Duan Tham Suvintheran Thangavelu Simon-Djamel Thiberville Jananee Thirumanickam Emma C. Thomson Surain Raaj Thurai Peter S Timashev Noémie Tissot Jordan Zhien Toh Sia Loong Tonnii Marta Torre Margarida Torres Théo Treoux Tiffany Trouillon Christelle Tual Lance C.W. Turtle PG Ishara Udayanga Timothy M. Uyeki Luís Val-Flores Amélie Valran Marcel van den Berge Job van der Palen Paul van der Valk Peter Van der Voort Jarne Van Hattem Carolien van Netten Ilonka van Veen Noémie Vanel Shoban Raj Vasudayan Charline Vauchy Shaminee Veeran Aurélie Veislinger James Vickers José Ernesto Vidal César Vieira Benoit Visseaux Fanny Vuotto Noor Hidayu Wahab Suhaila Abdul Wahab Nadirah Abdul Wahid Tan Pei Wen Sanne Wesselius Nicole White Paul Henri Wicky Aurélie Wiedemann Calvin Wong Xin Ci Wong Yew Sing Wong Teck Fung Wong Gan Ee Xian Lim Saio Xian Kuan Pei Xuan Siti Rohani Yakop Nicholas Yee Hing Chian Hui Yeoh Obada Yousif Marion Zabbe Masliza Zahid Maram Zahran Nor Zaila Zaidan Konrad Zawadka Nurul Zaynah Hiba Zayyad David Zucman
Source :
BMJ Paediatrics Open, Vol 6, Iss 1 (2022)
Publication Year :
2022
Publisher :
BMJ Publishing Group, 2022.
Abstract
Background The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on paediatric populations varied between high-income countries (HICs) versus low-income to middle-income countries (LMICs). We sought to investigate differences in paediatric clinical outcomes and identify factors contributing to disparity between countries.Methods The International Severe Acute Respiratory and Emerging Infections Consortium (ISARIC) COVID-19 database was queried to include children under 19 years of age admitted to hospital from January 2020 to April 2021 with suspected or confirmed COVID-19 diagnosis. Univariate and multivariable analysis of contributing factors for mortality were assessed by country group (HICs vs LMICs) as defined by the World Bank criteria.Results A total of 12 860 children (3819 from 21 HICs and 9041 from 15 LMICs) participated in this study. Of these, 8961 were laboratory-confirmed and 3899 suspected COVID-19 cases. About 52% of LMICs children were black, and more than 40% were infants and adolescent. Overall in-hospital mortality rate (95% CI) was 3.3% [=(3.0% to 3.6%), higher in LMICs than HICs (4.0% (3.6% to 4.4%) and 1.7% (1.3% to 2.1%), respectively). There were significant differences between country income groups in intervention profile, with higher use of antibiotics, antivirals, corticosteroids, prone positioning, high flow nasal cannula, non-invasive and invasive mechanical ventilation in HICs. Out of the 439 mechanically ventilated children, mortality occurred in 106 (24.1%) subjects, which was higher in LMICs than HICs (89 (43.6%) vs 17 (7.2%) respectively). Pre-existing infectious comorbidities (tuberculosis and HIV) and some complications (bacterial pneumonia, acute respiratory distress syndrome and myocarditis) were significantly higher in LMICs compared with HICs. On multivariable analysis, LMIC as country income group was associated with increased risk of mortality (adjusted HR 4.73 (3.16 to 7.10)).Conclusion Mortality and morbidities were higher in LMICs than HICs, and it may be attributable to differences in patient demographics, complications and access to supportive and treatment modalities.
Details
Language :
English
ISSN :
23999772
Volume :
6
Issue :
1
Database :
Directory of Open Access Journals
Journal :
BMJ Paediatrics Open
Publication Type :
Academic Journal
Accession number :
edsdoj.2d6e33f041524e2691c04a9a5d86431c
Document Type :
article
Full Text :
https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjpo-2022-001657