Third molar development according to chronological age in populations from Spanish and Magrebian origin

To link to full-text access for this article, visit this link: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.forsciint.2007.03.009 Byline: Stella Martin-de las Heras (a), Pedro Garcia-Fortea (b), Angie Ortega (a), Sara Zodocovich (c), Aurora Valenzuela (a) Keywords: Forensic odontology; Dental age estimation; Third molar mineralization; Ethnicity Abstract: Spain is frequently the entrance country into the European Union for undocumented immigrants, especially those from the Magreb (Northern Africa). Forensic age estimates for these persons are difficult because systematic studies of dental maturity are lacking. Three different populations were analyzed to determine the pattern of development of third molars as a tool for age estimation in people of different ethnic and geographic origin. Orthopantomograms from two different populations of Spanish origin (Galicia in northwestern continental Spain, and Ceuta, a Spanish province in Northern Africa) were compared to radiographs of molars from a Magrebian population (Northern Africa) resident in Ceuta. Orthopantomograms were obtained from a private dental clinic (n =344) in Galicia and from the Public Oral Health Services (n =228) in Ceuta. We looked for differences in third molar mineralization (determined with the Demirjian scale) that might serve as age indicators (older versus younger than 18 years). Differences in maturation patterns were found between sexes and populations of origin. Mineralization of tooth 38 was more advanced in males than females among subjects 18 years of age and older in all three populations. Moreover, mineralization of tooth 38 in subjects aged 18 years and older was significantly slower in the Spanish-Galicia population than in the Magrebian-Ceuta population. We found no significant differences between Magrebian and Spanish individuals from Ceuta. We conclude that differences in tooth 38 mineralization may be related more with socio-geographical than ethnic origin (ancestry), and thus constitute evidence of the relevance of socio-geographic rather than genetic factors in third molar development. We used ROC analysis to determine the accuracy of the examiner's ability to correctly estimate age as younger or older than 18 years. The results suggest that Demirjian stage for tooth 38 can be considered a good indicator of age in all three populations. Author Affiliation: (a) Department of Forensic Medicine and Forensic Odontology, University of Granada, Avenida de Madrid 11, 18071 Granada, Spain (b) Health Department, Government Office, Malaga, Spain (c) Private Dental Practice, Ferrol, Spain Article History: Received 5 March 2007; Accepted 13 March 2007