1. Reactions to experts in deliberative democracy: the 2016–2018 Irish Citizens' Assembly.
- Author
-
Müller, Stefan, Kennedy, Garrett, and Maher, Tomás
- Subjects
- *
DELIBERATIVE democracy , *CITIZENS , *IRISH people , *POLITICAL participation , *CITIZEN attitudes , *TRANSCRIPTION (Linguistics) - Abstract
Many citizens support the involvement of experts in political decision-making, yet we know little about how citizens react to expert opinions. Bridging recent evidence on technocratic attitudes and deliberative democracy, we study citizen responses to experts during influential deliberative mini-publics. Combining automated speech transcription of over 380,000 spoken words and quantitative text analysis, we estimate the topic prevalence in all expert testimonials, Q&A sessions, and other agenda items in the Irish Citizens' Assembly (2016–2018), one of the prime examples of impactful deliberative forums. We find that inputs of experts structure subsequent discussions but do not dominate them. This correlation persists with various measures of topic prevalence and is robust to several modelling approaches. We also find that participants tended to react less strongly to testimonials by female experts. These conditional effects should encourage organisers to invite experts with diverse backgrounds in order to enhance inclusive decision-making. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2023
- Full Text
- View/download PDF