1. DIFFERENTIATION IN THE PERSPICUITY OF SCRIPTURE AND ITS EFFECT ON THE APPLICATION OF SCRIPTURE'S AUTHORITY.
- Author
-
Wagner, Brian Henry
- Subjects
- *
LITERATURE , *CHRISTIANITY , *CHRISTIANS , *CHURCH - Abstract
The direction of research for this topic included surveying all the major literature concerning the doctrine of the perspicuity of Scripture during the history of the Church, especially from the time of the Protestant Reformation to the present. Those who have written significantly about the perspicuity of Scripture, whose writings have been reviewed, include the reformers Luther, Zwingli, and Hubmaier. Also reviewed are the enlightenment evangelicals Francis Turretin and John Owen, and modern theologians Wayne Grudem, Mark Thompson, Greg Allison and Michael Stallard. A special emphasis was made to report from these writings any recognized levels of objective clarity as well as any associations made between Biblical clarity and the application of its authority. Next, a survey was made of the Scripture concerning its own perspicuity, plus a careful exegesis added of significant passages in which perspicuity was directly discussed. The views of Christ, Moses, David, and Ezra concerning the clarity of OT Scripture and OT texts such as Deuteronomy 30:14-"But the word is very near you"4 and Psalm 19:7-"The testimony of the LORD is sure, making wise the simple" have been given special attention. NT texts such as John 5:39-"Search the Scriptures" and 2 Corinthians 1:13-"For we are not writing any other things to you than what you read or understand" have also been exegeted as primary texts concerning the perspicuity of Scripture. And 1 Corinthians 13:8-12 and 2 Peter 3:14- 16, which mention "now we see in a mirror, dimly," and "some things hard to understand," were exegeted in reference to the occasions of evident obscurity found 4 All Scripture quotations unless otherwise noted from the New King James Version, Nashville, TN: Nelson, 1981. xv in Scriptures. Finally, three main passages relating authoritative categories in Scripture are also analyzed. They are 1 Corinthians 15:3-4 concerning the gospel, Titus 1:5 and 9 concerning sound doctrine, and Romans 14:1 concerning doubtful matters. And this survey of Scripture included a discussion of the implied perspicuity found in the literary genres of history and command that Scripture uses abundantly. Next, a useful grid or formula has been sought, attempted, and developed that can be used to assess the perspicuity level of any passage in Scripture, and by inference, any doctrinal issue mentioned in those passages. Tools like the Flesch Reading Ease diagnostic or the Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level readability test have been considered. An attempt has been made to develop a reasonable method of attributing degrees of clarity to various genres of literature, word frequencies, and context integration found in Scripture. The English text of Scripture was mainly utilized for such testing, providing only a framework, and making necessary the future research which will test the perspicuity of Scripture in editions made from original language texts. The assessment tool that has been manufactured is only a prototype that hopefully will be modified and improved upon by succeeding generations. However, it is also hoped that it may immediately begin to help as an objective, unbiased judge for the evangelical community concerning the "doubtful things" (Rom. 14:1) that presently divide it (i.e., where opposite sides both claim to have "clear" Scriptural support), which according to the law of non-contradiction is impossible. Finally, this dissertation included research that used a few practical examples where the doctrine of Scripture's objective clarity aided in identifying 1) a doctrine xvi that should be excluded from the gospel that some have included, 2) a doctrine that should be included as sound doctrine (a qualification criteria for elders in the church) that some have excluded, and 3) an example of an objectively unclear doctrine that should be excluded from sound doctrine that some have included. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2012