1. Narrative Retribution and Cognitive Processing.
- Author
-
Grizzard, Matthew, Fitzgerald, Kaitlin, Francemone, C. Joseph, Ahn, Changhyun, Huang, Jialing, Walton, Jess, McAllister, Cass, and Lewis, Robert Joel
- Subjects
NARRATION ,RETRIBUTION ,EVOLUTIONARY psychology ,SATISFACTION ,PLEASURE ,COGNITIVE science ,DISPOSITION (Philosophy) - Abstract
In both narrative theory and evolutionary psychology, equitable-retribution —or the idea that punishments for committing a moral transgression should be equivalent to the transgression itself—is a centerpiece of discussion. This article reports results from a blocked within-subjects experiment that examined speed of cognitive processing and subjective rating of three types of narrative retribution: equitable-retribution; under-retribution, where punishment is absent for a transgression; and over-retribution, where punishment exceeds the severity of the transgression. Results suggest that narrative endings depicting equitable-retribution are processed more quickly and liked more than endings with under-retribution and over-retribution. In addition, liking seems to correspond with enjoyment for equitable-retribution and over-retribution; for under-retribution, liking seems to correspond with appreciation. Discussion focuses on implications for theory and extending the current experimental paradigm. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF