Search

Red blood cell allo-immunization is the immune response of an individual to foreign red blood cell antigens not present on the surface of their own cells. The aim of that paper is to clarify the different factors influencing the antibody response against red blood cell antigens., (Copyright © 2012 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.)

The technology allowing freezing of RBC units has been available for many decades. The high-glycerol method for RBC storage at -8 degrees C is predominantly used. Several studies have shown satisfactory results regarding the in vitro viability and function of cryopreserved RBCs. RBC freezing is nowadays mostly encountered in rare blood programs and military deployments. Preservation time of frozen RBCs appears to be virtually indefinite, but most countries apply a 10-year outdate. There is no mandatory time restriction in France. The National Rare Blood Bank currently includes 962 (17.5%) RBC units aged to years or more and 153 (2.8%) aged 20 years or more. Since 1994, 1957 RBC units have been thawed and transfused, among which 118 were aged 10 years or more and 8 were aged 20 years or more. Discarding RBC units older than to years may be highly sensitive for very rare blood groups, e.g., U-, of which approximately 30 percent of the cryopreserved units are aged to years or more. However, the lack of nucleic acid testing for HIV and HCV may be problematic for old RBC units drawn from donors who were not subsequently tested for these markers, which is now mandatory in most countries. Regarding the 118 transfused RBC units older than 10 years, no evidence of hemolysis of thawed RBCs and no transfusion reaction, clinical or biologic hemolysis, or transfusion ineffectiveness was reported, either by any of the parties involved in the transfusion supply of rare RBC units or through the French hemovigilance program, which requires a mandatory report of any transfusion reaction. It has recently been suggested to extend the 10-year restriction in some countries. Considering our experience and observational data, we may consider it safe and efficient to transfuse rare frozen RBC units older than 10 years. An international consensus for RBC cryopreservation time should ideally be established.

A rare blood group is usually defined as the absence of a high prevalence antigen or the absence of several antigens within a single blood group system, if its prevalence in France is 4/1000 or less in the general population. An individual with a rare blood phenotype can develop a naturally-occurring or immune antibody corresponding to his rare specificity. In case an extremely low stock of compatible blood is available at the national level, a so-called "transfusion deadlock" is described. Most of the individuals with a rare blood group are coincidently identified when a routine pretransfusion testing or pregnancy follow-up is performed, if the antibody(ies) corresponding to the rare specificity is(are) present. Other individuals are discovered following a systematic red cell typing, or family investigations in siblings. One hundred and twenty-one rare blood specificities and 42 rare blood genotypes are currently defined at the French National Reference Laboratory for Blood Groups (CNRGS-Paris). The French national registry of individuals with a rare blood phenotype/genotype includes about 9600 people, who are urged to regularly donate blood for the National Rare Blood Bank. This bank, based on a homologous blood transfusion program, is in charge of the long-term storage of rare frozen blood units, that can only be delivered after receiving authorization from the CNRGS. The global and individual care management of the individuals with a rare blood group, concerning potentially several hundred thousand people in France, requires a close cooperation between all the protagonists within the transfusion chain.

For ten years, the working party of immunohaematology of the French Society of Blood Transfusion organizes a quality control. After the modification of the law about the realization of erythrocyte typing and detection of unexpected red cell allo-antibodies, the quality control was performed in order to determine the sensitivity of the indirect antiglobulin test by filtration with a standard anti-RH1(D) produces by the National Reference Center of Blood Groups.

In 2004, the French Reference Centre for Rare Blood Groups and Immunohaematology (CNRGS) developed 7 types of activities: 1) Studies of complex Immunohaematology issues (IH), 2) Studies of rare blood phenotypes, 3) the transfusion of patients showing complex issues, 4) IH reactive control in consistency with the 98/79/CE European Directive, 5) European studies and expertise on reactives and techniques, 6) Biotechnologies applied to blood groups, in particular RH, KEL, FY, JK, DO and CO, 7) Implementation of allo-immunization research programs (cellular immunology and grafting issues). The CNRGS efficiency is based on the 'reference-research' link thanks to the Inserm partnership and direct applications to patients allowing to a better risk management and control.

One hundred and forty five Mabs against RH antigens were tested. In this paper, we chose to detail reactivity of MoAbs directed against variant RBCs of the CNRGS collection for which we studied the molecular background. Because we developed procedures to identify variants of the RhD, RhC, RhE and Rhe antigens, we were especially interested in finding new monoclonal antibodies that could help us to characterize more accurately these variants. Therefore, we drew parallels between our procedures and results obtained with the 2001 workshop antibodies.

The French reference laboratory for rare blood groups (CNRGS) is working for all participants of the transfusion chain: from the donors to the recipients; from the French Establishment for Blood to medical laboratories; from hospital to the haemovigilance network; from governmental agencies to European structures. This laboratory is in charge of: (1) studies of complex problems of immunohaematology; (2) studies of rare blood group phenotypes; (3) reagents quality controls; (4) production of biological standards; (5) specific specimen banks; (6) molecular studies of blood group antigens and antibodies involved; (8) panels of reference cells or DNA; (9) international exchanges.

Six unrelated individuals of Afro-Caribbean origin, whose red cells have a marked reduction of the Rhe antigen expression, have been identified. All exhibited the same serological profile with anti-e monoclonal antibodies and lacked expression of the high frequency e-related antigen hrS. Transcripts and genomic analysis showed that these phenotypes resulted from the presence of two new RHCE alleles, ceMO and cEMI. The ceMO allele corresponded to a RHce gene carrying a G667T mutation (exon 5) and was detected at the homozygous state in sample 1 and at the heterozygous state in samples 2-6. The G667T mutation resulted in a Val223Phe substitution on the Rhce polypeptide, in close proximity to Ala226 (e-antigen polymorphism), which might account for the altered expression of e. The ceMO allele is also associated with the lack of expression of the hrS antigen. The absence of the hrS antigen expression may have implications in transfusion as hrS-negative individuals may develop clinically significant antibodies. The cEMI allele corresponded to a silent RHE allele carrying a nine nucleotide deletion within exon 3 and was detected at the heterozygous state in sample 2. This deletion resulted in a shortened polypeptide of 414 residues (instead of 417) that was absent (or severely reduced) at the red cell surface, as the E antigen was undetectable using serology and Western blot analysis with anti-E reagents. In DNA-based polymerase chain reaction genotyping for RHE determination, the cEMI allele provided a false positive result as the cells carrying this allele are serologically phenotyped as E-negative. The incidence of this allele in the Black population is unknown but, as shown already for D genotyping, one must exercise caution when genotyping is performed to detect the e/E polymorphism.

Immunoglobulin preparations of anti-D (RH1) are injected to prevent haemolytic disease of the newborn. Such preparations are obtained by the fractionation of plasma from immunized donors. Measurement of the concentration of IgG anti-D is required to estimate the potency of anti-D preparations and sera from immunized donors. We have developed an ELISA method for the quantification of IgG anti-D. This method included the following steps, sensitization of red cells by anti-D, solubilization of red cell membranes by Triton, and eventually, measurement of IgG anti-D concentration by ELISA. The international reference preparation of anti-D (68/419) was used as a reference. With this method, we measured IgG anti-D concentrations in 5 immunoglobulin preparations of anti-D and in the sera of 10 donors immunized by D antigen. The ELISA results were compared with those obtained by automated hemagglutination. A mean anti-D concentration of 56.2 micrograms/mL was found by ELISA in immunoglobulin preparations. Similar results were obtained by automated hemagglutination (mean 52 micrograms/mL). In the sera of 10 D-immunized donors, anti-D IgG concentration varied from 2.2 to 59.8 micrograms/mL. A good correlation between ELISA and automated hemagglutination was observed in these sera (r = 0.98, p < 10(-7)). In conclusion, the ELISA technique offers an alternative to automated hemagglutination. It requires only the standard equipment necessary for immuno-enzymatic methods.

Until the 1980s blood group reagents had been produced from human or animal plasmas. Since then, the main change has been the increase of the use of monoclonal antibodies in laboratory reagents. Today, they are the basis of most reagents for blood group typing. They include murine (hybridomas) and human (Epstein-Barr virus immortalized lymphocytes and phage display) antibodies. The use of these antibodies leads to standardized methods of production and a better definition of the specificity through international works. The main drawback is the lack of antibodies for some blood group antigens. However, in the future these methods will be confronted with the development of DNA-based methods.

The immunologic risk associated to erythrocyte transfusions is bound to the polymorphism of blood group systems and to the respect of blood transfusion regulations. The results of three studies are presented, which were carried out respectively by the French Society of Blood Transfusion, the National Institute of Blood Transfusion and the National Haemovigilance Network. Two hundred and twenty-seven cases of immunologic accidents are analysed using the Kaplan's interpretation model and the traditional method of process analysis. The results show three critical factors in the occurrence of this type of incident: the relevance of the clinical examinations prescribed, the way in which the biological results are taken into account, and the relationship/exchange of information between private and public hospitals, and blood transfusion centers.

The risks associated to red cell and platelet transfusions are essentially bound to the polymorphism of blood group antigens and to transfusion transmitted agents including virus, bacterias.... In France, the haemovigilance system and several investigations allowed to measure these different kinds of risks. We also developed analysis of failures in order to prevent errors and accidents to increase blood safety.

The reagents used for blood group analyses are subject in France to the same regulations as other reagents. A file must be submitted for each reagent to the Agence française de sécurité sanitaire des produits de santé. Furthermore, each production lot must be checked by the Centre national de référence pour les groupes sanguins (CNRGS) for control before marketing. These controls allow a comparative quality assessment of the reagents. The investigation by the CNRGS of the problems encountered in the every day use of these products makes this quality control even more accurate.

The national reference Center for blood groups checked samples of reagents and devices used in France for a definitive verification of pretransfusion ABO tests performed at the patient's bedside, as defined by French health authority regulations. The results of an initial inquiry was published in 1991. The new study shows no significant improvement of the quality of reagents and devices. This is a major concern considering the importance of ABO incompatibility in severe hemolytic transfusion reactions.

After testing red cells from 12 RhE variants with a panel of anti-E monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs), four patterns of reactivity were detected indicating that the MoAbs may recognize four distinct E epitopes designated epE1, epE2, epE3 and epE4. The variants were classified into four categories (cat EI to EIV) which carried epE1 and epE2, epE1 and epE4, epE1, epE3 and epE4, and all four epitopes, respectively. Molecular analysis of the transcripts and genomic DNA of the variants from cat EI, EII and EIII displayed three distinct genetic alterations. Cat EI variants exhibited a point mutation (T500A) in exon 4 of the RHCE gene that resulted in a Met167Lys substitution in the third extracellular loop of the RhcE protein. Cat EII variant carried a hybrid gene structure characterized by replacement of exons 1-3 (or 2-3) of the RHCE gene by their specific counterparts in the RHD gene. This latter variant was also associated with a weak expression of the RhC antigen. In cat EIII variants there was a partial DNA exchange of exon 5 sequences (nt 697 and 712) between the RHCE and the RHD genes, generating a hybrid Rh cE-D-cE protein carrying the Glu233 and Val238 substitutions. The serological and molecular studies of the RhE variants indicated that: (i) the RhE antigen is a mosaic composed of at least four epitopes and proline at position 226 is necessary but not sufficient for the full expression of the E antigen, (ii) the lack of RhE epitope(s) is associated with heterogenous molecular alterations of the RHCE gene, and (iii) amino-acids located on the third and fourth extracellular loops of the RhCE polypeptide are critical for some RhE epitopes expression.

The Duffy (FY) blood group antigens are carried by the DARC glycoprotein, a widely expressed chemokine receptor. The molecular basis of the Fya/Fyb and Fy(a-b-) polymorphisms has been clarified, but little is known about the Fyx antigen and the FY*X allele associated with weak expression of Fyb, Fy3, Fy5, and Fy6 antigens. We analyzed here the structure and expression of the FY gene in 4 Fy(a-bweak) individuals. As compared with Fy(a-b+) controls, the Fy(a-bweak) red blood cell membranes contained residual amount of DARC polypeptide and these cells were poorly bound by anti-Fy antibodies and chemokines. The FY gene from Fy(a-b+) and Fy(a-bweak) individuals differed by one substitution, C286T. The resulting Arg89Cys amino acid change reduced the binding of anti-Fy antibodies and chemokines to DARC transfectants. We concluded that the Fybweak donors carried the FY*X allele at the FY locus and that the Fyx antigen corresponds to highly reduced expression of a grossly normal Fyb polypeptide caused by the Arg89Cys substitution. Because FY is a single copy gene, this defect should also affect DARC expression in nonerythroid cells. Because the Fyx phenotype is not associated with apparent clinical consequences, we discussed these findings in the light of the putative roles of DARC in various tissues. Finally, we developed a Fyx DNA typing assay that should be useful for genetic studies and clinical transfusion medicine., (Copyright 1998 by The American Society of Hematology.)

The RH blood group locus is composed of two sequence-related genes, RHD and RHCE, encoding the D, Cc, and Ee antigens in common Rh-positive phenotypes. In this report, we have analyzed the molecular basis of Rh antigens expression in weak D (Du) and RN donors, in whom there is a severe reduction of the D and C/e antigens, respectively. Genomic and transcript analysis of three unrelated low-grade weak D (Du) variants indicated that the very low expression of the D antigen is not the result of rearrangement or mutation in the coding sequence of the RHO gone. Accordingly, weak D (Du) erythrocytes should carry a normal RhD polypeptide, which is in agreement with the observation that these variants never produce anti-D antibodies. Comparative polymerase chain reaction analysis showed a lower steady-state level of RhD transcripts in weak D (Du) reticulocytes, as compared with normal RhD-positive controls, thus providing direct evidence that the difference between the D antigen of D-positive and weak D (Du) red blood cells is quantitative only. Conversely, analysis of the molecular genetic basis of the RN phenotype Indicated that the severely decreased expression of the RhC and Rhe antigens in three variants is associated with a qualitative alteration identified as a segmental DNA exchange between the RHCE and RHD genes. These genomic rearrangements, which resulted in hybrid RhCe-D-Ce proteins expressing the low frequency Rh32 but not the high incidence Rh46 antigens, involved either axon 4 alone or both exons 3 and 4. These findings show that an identical phenotypical alteration of Rh antigens (reduced expression) may result either from a quantitative or a qualitative alteration of the RH genes expression.

The LW blood group is carried by a 42-kD glycoprotein that belongs to the family of intercellular adhesion molecules. The LW gene is organized into three exons spanning an HindIII fragment of approximately 2.65 kb. The exon/intron architecture correlates to the structural domains of the protein and resembles that of other Ig superfamily members except that the signal peptide and the first Ig-like domain are encoded by the first exon. The 5'UT region (nucleotides -289 to +9) includes potential binding sites for various transcription factors (Ets, CACC, SP1, GATA-1, AP2) and exhibited a significant transcriptional activity after transfection in the erythroleukemic K562 cells. No obvious abnormality of the LW gene, including the 5'UT region, has been detected by sequencing polymerase chain reaction-amplified genomic DNA from RhD+ or RhD- donors and from an Rhnull variant that lacks the Rh and LW proteins on red blood cells. However, a deletion of 10 bp in exon 1 of the LW gene was identified in the genome of an LW (a- b-) individual (Big) deficient for LW antigens but carrying a normal Rh phenotype. The 10-bp deletion generates a premature stop codon and encodes a truncated protein without transmembrane and cytoplasmic domain. No detectable abnormality of the LW gene or transcript could be detected in another LW(a- b-) individual (Nic), suggesting the heterogeneity of these phenotypes.

The immunological risk of red blood cell transfusions now seems higher than the viral risk. According to studies, severe accidents due to blood incompatibility occur with a frequency estimated at 1/6000 to 1/29000; despite technical progress, the risk does not significantly diminish. The majority of accidents do not originate from laboratory or production stages but from defects in the application of clinical procedures. Preventive measures are based on (i) the elaboration of clinical guidelines, (ii) the compliance to strict rules in carrying out bedside ABO check, and (iii) the realization and interpretation of antibody screening tests. The implementation of quality assurance systems and of the epidemiological surveillance system, which define the basis of a prevention policy, leads to the expectation of an improvement of transfusion safety.

Immunological transfusion reactions more than often lead to an activation of the complement proteins and mononuclear cells, inducing a haemolysis from which stem the observed clinical symptoms. In the case of incompatibility, the alloantibodies can lead to an immediate reaction, taking place in the first few minutes or, in the case of a delayed reaction, arising after 24 hours. A standardized clinical and biological evaluation is necessary in order to confirm the diagnosis and to assess the consequences of the antigen-antibody conflict.

The Société Française de Transfusion Sanguine and the Centre National de Référence pour les Groupes Sanguins performed a quality control to evaluate the performances of two serological tests: the Direct Antiglobulin Test (DAT) and the Elution test. Among the 110 Blood Transfusion Centers participating in this control, 80 (73%) returned a result. Of these, 68 results were correct for the DAT (85%; positive for type IgG) and 31 results were correct for the elution (39%; anti-FY1). This control gave the opportunity to confirm the main procedures used in routine testing on a national scale. The analysis of the results underlines the importance of the choice of a standardized technique for these tests. Such controls are useful to appreciate the quality of the routine tests and to find the means to improve them.

Blood transfusion is mainly bound to immunological and infectious risks. The immunological risk originates from an incompatibility between the blood of the donor and that of the recipient; this risk remains insufficiently assessed. A multicentre study has been carried out by the French Blood Transfusion Society and the National Institute for Blood Transfusion. Sixty-one accidents due to an erythrocyte incompatibility were found: 26 cases with ABO incompatibility, and 35 cases with alloantibodies of other blood group systems. For the former category of accidents, the most frequent cause was due to a failure in the realization of the bedside ABO check. For the latter, the main problem was the achievement and the interpretation of antibody screening. The long term follow-up shows no chronic after-effects of immunological accidents. For each accident, errors have been identified and analysed. It was proven that they all originate from health care establishments.